High Five for Five Guys

Written by Doug\. Filed under NY/CT. Tagged , , . Bookmark the Permalink. Post a Comment. Leave a Trackback URL.

I drove home from Five Guys wondering how much money the chain is planning on contributing to President Obama’s 2012 re-election campaign.  The man has given them enormous — and free — publicity.  Heck, I’d never even heard of Five Guys until I read about Obama’s visits there.

Now that I’ve been, I can tell you this:  They make a very good fast food burger.   Not on par with the best of restaurant burgers — you can’t compare it to a thick, char-grilled Squire’s burger for instance — but it blows McDonald’s and Burger King out of the water.

Here are the observations about Five Guys:

1. You can go to the location in Nanuet and not worry about running into a Presidential motorcade:

2. Five Guys has a devoted following.  Customers were streaming in.  I heard one man in line ask his friend, “What’s good?”  ”Everything!” his friend replied enthusiastically.

3. The menu is simple to navigate: burgers, hot dogs, and fries. That’s it.

4. “Little” burgers are single patties.  All other  burgers come as double patties.  I didn’t realize that at first. I’d contemplated ordering two regular cheeseburgers until I saw they were doubles.  That would have been a bit much.

5.  Burger toppings are free and include your usuals — lettuce, tomato, pickles — plus other toppings like jalapenos, grilled onions, grilled peppers and A-1 sauce. (Which in all my life, I’ve never seen someone actually use.  Didn’t even know they made A-1 anymore.)

6. Food at Five Guys is made to order; nothing is sitting around or pre-packaged.   The burger patties are pressed and cooked on a flat griddle, and they even toast the buns!

5. The kosher hot dogs look really good.  Split and grilled.

6. Because everything is made to order, you’ll wait a bit longer for your food than you would at McDonald’s.  But it’s not long, just a few minutes.  And it wouldn’t have been a problem had I not come straight from a workout in a ravenous state.   I swear, I almost jumped over the glass partition like Spiderman to snag one of the burgers on the griddle.

7. The Cajun fries are crispy and fantastic, and portion size is out of control.  A heaping “regular” order of fries came in an overflowing cup that spilled into the bag.  It was enough for two or three people.  I shudder to think what constitutes a “large.”

8. And finally, the burgers.  I ordered a cheeseburger with lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, jalapenos and grilled mushrooms. Thinnish patties (but there were two of them!) that were juicy and tasted like real beef, not processed like at other fast food joints.  Everything was fresh, and I loved having so many topping options.  A very good burger.

9. Oh, and another thing: the employees were efficient and the woman at the register was friendly, giving a smile and a “Have a nice day.”  Not a big deal maybe, but we live in a society where customer service is going down the toilet and people are more surly than Michael Bloomberg meeting the press. I appreciate little friendly touches.

10. As of now, Nanuet is the only Five Guys location in the Westchester/Rockland area.  That won’t last.  Five Guys is going to catch on quickly, and I predict more locations popping up. How about Chappaqua?  If we can’t get Obama, at least former President Clinton could stop in.  I have a feeling he likes burgers.

Five Guys
43 East Rte. 59
Nanuet, NY
845-623-1863

3 Comments

  1. Cheryl
    Posted June 8, 2009 at 9:20 am | Permalink

    Doug:

    Thanks for checking this place out– enquiring minds want to know!

    Next time you are in Rockland, may I suggest that you try Bailey’s Smokehouse off of Rte. 303 in Blauvelt? The place kicks butt over any BBQ place in Westchester (homemade potato chips! gumbo du jour! corn souffle!), and the ribs are good too. Go hungry.

  2. Michele
    Posted June 11, 2009 at 8:14 am | Permalink

    I agree with you 100%. Five Guys in Nanuet is great. And Cheryl I agree with you 100%, Bailey’s is great. They just added Southern Fried Chicken to their menu. I will need to put my current diet to the side to try it. Have you had it yet? They even put a permanent sign up on the outside wall announcing it. It must be pretty darn good if they’ve done that, or – I just fall easily for clever advertising…
    p.s. if you go to Bailey’s and like hot stuff, get a side of the “Screaming Chicken” sauce with your order. It’s a full of flavor hot sauce. However, do not order your dish to be prepared with it (like wings), or you will scream like a chicken. A dab or 2 is all you need.

  3. Doug\
    Posted June 11, 2009 at 12:26 pm | Permalink

    Thanks Cheryl and Michele! It’s tough finding good BBQ — Bailey’s sounds like THE place. Might have to get some kind of combo platter of ribs, gumbo and fried chicken, with a side of hot sauce.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>